Odysseus’s Scar
Image Caption: Matt Damon as Odysseus in Christopher Nolan’s The Odyssey (2026)
Odysseus Today
We begin with the reinterpretation of Odysseus as a man in search of meaning. Antonio Musarra, associate professor of medieval history at Sapienza University of Rome, told Páginas Digital: “Over time, not only has our perception of Odysseus changed, but so has what he represents. That evolution allows us to see him today as a multifaceted figure: a man searching for meaning and hungry for knowledge, a great explorer, and a soul tormented by rootlessness. This rich layering of meaning stems from the countless interpretations that have emerged over the centuries.”
Antonio Monda, a professor in New York University’s Tisch School of the Arts Department of Film and Television offers a different perspective. “Ulysses is eternal; he transcends both past and present,” Monda says. “We shouldn’t try to force him into a modern box, because he embodies something permanently woven into the human condition. Ulysses simply is.”
For Monda, what matters most are the hero’s inherent contradictions, which make him both universal and timeless. “He is a cunning and ruthless man,” Monda continues, “yet he is also a man desperate to return home to the people he loves. He makes mistakes, he betrays, and he loses his way time and again—yet deep down, he knows exactly where he needs to go. Ultimately, he is a mortal capable of outwitting the gods and standing his ground against them.”
Juan José Gómez Cadenas, an Ikerbasque research professor at the Donostia International Physics Center and the author of Abandonando Ítaca (Leaving Ithaca), spoke with Páginas Digital about why the Homeric hero still resonates so deeply today.
“That’s not an easy question to answer, not least because there isn’t just one Odysseus,” he says. “The figure we meet in the Iliad is extraordinarily shrewd, yet devoid of mercy and basic human empathy. The hero of the Odyssey, by contrast, is far more nuanced: he is a man fighting to get home, genuinely driven by love for his son and his wife, Penelope—and that makes him infinitely more human.”
Still, Gómez Cadenas notes, Homer’s Odysseus is not the idealized hero many people imagine today. “If you read the end of the poem closely, when he finally reaches Ithaca and confronts the suitors vying for Penelope’s hand, he slaughters every last one of them with breathtaking brutality. Over the millennia, as our moral sensibilities have evolved, we have had to reckon with that savagery. Even so, he feels remarkably modern because he is a man battling to return to the arms of those he loves. He doesn’t fight his way back to Ithaca for power or political ambition, but simply to be reunited with his family.”
The 21st-Century Odysseus
Our second question is: Who will the 21st-century Odysseus be?
Musarra answers: “The new challenge of modernity is allowing Odysseus to navigate the complexities of everyday life and guide us back home. You don’t need to set sail to experience an odyssey anymore; the trials Odysseus faced stare us in the face every single day, and facing them is no less adventurous or heroic.”
“Furthermore,” he continues, “after World War II, Odysseus became the archetype of the returning veteran. Let me put it this way: Can a soldier ever truly come home and still be the person he was before? More to the point, does war irrevocably alter a man, leaving the destruction he took part in permanently etched into his soul? Viewed in this light, Odysseus becomes a meditation on violence—a man fighting to hold on to his memory so he doesn’t lose himself entirely. Today’s Odysseus is the person who loses his bearings and battles to stay afloat in the turbulent sea of everyday life.”
For Gómez Cadenas, however, the focus belongs on Odysseus’s crushing guilt and his quest for redemption: “The remorse he carries for the horrors he committed is so overwhelming that, in Nolan’s interpretation, when he washes ashore on Calypso’s island, he spends seven long years consuming lotus flowers just to blot it all out.”
In Nolan’s film, Odysseus is portrayed as a man desperate to reach home so he can finally atone for his sins. No moment illustrates this better than his homecoming in Ithaca. Confronted with the problem of Penelope’s suitors, he orders his son to stand down so the boy won’t have blood on his hands—as if to say: “I have already done terrible things; I can bloody my hands one last time, my son, so that you never have to.”
Modern retellings, Gómez Cadenas suggests, almost always center on this possibility of redemption.
For Monda, the question remains wide open: “The trials Ulysses faced mirror the struggles any of us might encounter in our own lives, and I’m fascinated to see how humanity will confront the obstacles of this century.”
Ulysses in Dante and Tennyson
Among the countless ways the Homeric epic has been reimagined over the centuries, two stand out in sharp contrast: those of Dante Alighieri and Alfred, Lord Tennyson.
In Dante’s Inferno, the great Florentine poet condemns Ulysses to the Eighth Circle of Hell as a counselor of fraud—even though Canto XXVI of the Inferno makes it unmistakably clear how deeply Dante admires him. In Tennyson’s dramatic monologue “Ulysses”, the Victorian poet laureate reimagines the aging king as a man for whom life has meaning only so long as he keeps pushing toward new frontiers of knowledge.
“Dante’s Ulysses,” Musarra notes, “revolves around the tension between faith and reason. Dante is warning us that anyone who relies on unaided human reason alone is doomed.”
According to Gómez Cadenas, Dante used Ulysses “as a symbol of the ancient Greek dread of the hereafter. Ulysses bridges the realm of the living and the realm of the dead, speaking volumes about the terror the Greek world felt in the face of mortality.”
Monda calls this “a spot-on reading. Dante wants to spotlight everything noble and stirring in Ulysses’s spirit, even as the narrative takes a tragic turn with the shipwreck that seals his fate far from Ithaca.”
Tennyson’s Ulysses famously declares near the start of the poem: “I cannot rest from travel: I will drink / Life to the lees.” Responding to these lines, Gómez Cadenas observes: “Realizing that even making it back to Ithaca wasn’t enough captures a deeply tragic truth about human life—coming home after twenty years only to discover that the place you left behind no longer exists. Home has changed, and something irreplaceable has been lost forever.”
Later in the poem, Tennyson’s hero insists that merely surviving without striving is no life at all: “How dull it is to pause, to make an end, / To rust unburnish’d, not to shine in use!”
According to Musarra, these lines must be read against the backdrop of their time: “When this poem was published, Britain was at the height of its imperial expansion and in the throes of the Industrial Revolution. Tennyson sees in Ulysses the restless energy of the Western world—perhaps even elevating him into an emblem of British imperialism, an enterprise that can never stand still. Yet Homer’s actual Odysseus, in truth, does come to rest.”
Tennyson’s poem continues: “To follow knowledge like a sinking star, / Beyond the utmost bound of human thought.” As Monda points out, these lines are a direct nod to Dante’s famous verse: “You were not made to live like brutes, / but to pursue virtue and knowledge.”
Musarra agrees with that connection, while Gómez Cadenas takes the thought a step further: “Right there, you have the entire ethos of modernity in a nutshell. What’s remarkable is that this voyage began nearly three thousand years ago and is still underway today—as if Odysseus were still sailing on inside every one of us.”
Finally, reflecting on the poem’s iconic closing line—“To strive, to seek, to find, and not to yield”—Musarra concludes: “It distills the relentless drive that defined the Western world in the nineteenth century.”
The Contrast with Abraham
We also asked Ignacio Carbajosa, professor of the Old Testament and dean of the Faculty of Theology at San Dámaso Ecclesiastical University in Madrid, to compare the Homeric hero with the biblical figure of Abraham, whom he has studied extensively.
“While Odysseus holds up a mirror to the universal human condition, Abraham introduces something entirely new into human history—an encounter that continually reorients and clarifies our sense of self,” Carbajosa says. “In a way, there is a striking contrast between human longing, embodied by Odysseus, and a God who steps into history to call man by name, as He does with Abraham. At the same time, both men are wayfarers. Yet while Odysseus sets sail from Ithaca and is swept into the Trojan War by fate, Abraham leaves his homeland behind in response to an objective call, obeying for the very first time the voice of an Other who tells him: ‘Go from your country… to the land that I will show you.’”
The sharpest difference between the two figures, Carbajosa explains, lies in how they relate to the divine.
“On one hand, you have Greek mythology, which views human beings as at the mercy of the untamed forces of existence. Those forces—passion, the sun, death, the sea—are personified as icons: the gods. They represent aspects of reality and cosmic powers that dwarf human strength, which is why humanity’s posture toward them is always a mix of defiance and submission. In the experience of ancient Israel, by contrast, a book like Genesis emerges with a revolutionary claim in its very first chapter. For the first time in the ancient Near Eastern and Mediterranean world, it affirms that there is a single creative principle, that this Creator is good, and that everything He has brought into being is good.”
“That insight actually laid the groundwork for modern science. After all, if you are terrified that the sea might swallow you whole or the earth might strike you down at the whim of a capricious deity, nature is something to fear. When everything is created good and points back to its Creator, however, the physical world becomes an open invitation to inquiry—because exploring reality becomes a way of seeking its Maker.”
Asked what the 21st-century Odysseus and Abraham might look like, Carbajosa begins by pointing to the pitfalls of artificial intelligence.
“My concern is that leaning too heavily on this technology could atrophy our capacity to reason and to grapple deeply with reality. I’ve experimented with AI in my own work, and there’s no question it makes things more efficient. Yet true personal growth comes from the sweat and energy we invest in engaging with reality firsthand. That’s why I wonder whether we will need a few modern-day ‘Odysseuses’ who can keep their wits about them and help steer humanity forward.”
“Even so,” he concludes, “I am certain that Abraham will continue to play a vital role in our story—specifically in how the Christian message meets people in a world that is restlessly searching for answers. In the end, it is about allowing all of Odysseus’s deepest questions to encounter the Christian message and find their true home in a Father.”
