Listen

Share
Share
50
17.11.2026
We know how to defend freedom of expression. But who speaks up for the freedom to listen? J. Á. González Sainz explores the crucial difference between hearing and listening – and what we lose when noise and snap judgments take the place of genuine attention to others.

“Freedom of expression” has always been—and remains—one of the fundamental demands of any society that aspires to call itself civilized. But let’s not fool ourselves: a dark, relentless impulse toward incivility is always ready to gain ground the moment we grow complacent and lower our political and moral guard. The freedom to express ideas, arguments, or opinions that challenge the prevailing political orthodoxy—without fear of being discredited, driven from public life, or, in the most extreme cases, imprisoned or killed, as happens under despotic and totalitarian regimes of every ideological stripe—is undeniably a cornerstone of democracy and any civilized society.

Within such a society, it is hard to mount a legitimate objection to that principle. The trouble is that people often say one thing about free speech and do another. They insist that “freedom of expression” is guaranteed and vigorously defended while silencing, smearing, or punishing anyone who dares to disagree, whether an individual or a news organization. Anyone who, in the name of truth and free speech, dismisses a dissenting publication as “pseudo-media outlet” is only a step away from calling its contributors “pseudo-journalists” or “pseudo-writers”—and, eventually, “pseudo-people.” At that point, we have begun the moral descent that accompanies every process of dehumanization. It starts quietly,  almost casually, until, at the bottom of that slope, the victim is no longer a human being, but a “rat,” a “figure,” or a “silhouette” to be exterminated —to borrow the vocabulary of the Third Reich.

Yet while “freedom of expression”—each person’s right to say what they think, want, or believe, and to take responsibility for it– is firmly established among us as a prerequisite of civilized life, I have never heard or read anyone demand the freedom to listen. We seem to take it for granted, as though we already possessed it, as though listening were automatically a free act. No one champions the “freedom to listen” as an equally essential pillar of democracy and civilized life, much less as a basic condition for healthy, meaningful human relationships.

Consider why we so often leave conversations, dinner-table discussion, or public talks feeling irritated, withdrawn, or dissatisfied– with others and with ourselves. We don’t listen to one another. We don’t let what is being said truly reach us. At the slightest provocation, we throw up our ideological defenses and slam our minds shut like iron gates.  A single cue or detail is enough for us to pigeonhole everything we hear, mechanically labelling every remark as “good” or “bad.” Depending on the label, the speaker’s words either pass through our ideological filter—whose mesh tightens or loosens as circumstances require—or are summarily condemned to the flames reserved for heretics. At best, we hear those words as we might hear rain drumming on a roof. We never really  listen.

We lack the freedom to listen. We catch an opinion, an argument, a position, or a name—sometimes just a buzzword or a certain tone of voice—and immediately tune out, take aim with our judgement, and begin composing a rebuttal while the other person is still speaking. The moment we prepare to  dismiss what we hear, we stop listening. We cut ourselves off. We deny ourselves the freedom to listen; we take it away with our own hands. Unlike censorship imposed on speech, this restriction comes from no outside authority. We censor ourselves. We deprive ourselves of freedom. We become our own despots.

The most uncompromising censor of the freedom to listen is the fanatic: the zealot, the self-righteous believer who clings blindly to a dogma, whatever happens, in the service of whatever the Cause may be. Some grand, glittering Idea or Goal must take precedence over everything else, and everything must be sacrificed to it without hesitation– even if the consequences are economic ruin, social collapse, or mass slaughter. The very first sacrifice is the freedom to listen. If the fanatical lets go of the dogma that sustains his sense of superiority, his whole identity collapses. And once that inner structure gives away, nothing remains: he becomes cannon fodder, easy prey for scoundrels. A fanatic does not listen; he cannot afford to. He merely hears, pulls the trigger of emotion, and fires into action.

For anyone with eyes to see and ears to hear, language is constantly sounding the alarm. As always, and at every level—even the most intimate—language is our most reliable barometer. Over the past decade, for example, the distinction between “hearing” and “listening” has increasingly blurred, encouraged by the mass media and its dutiful servants, along with the public’s tireless appetite for the banalities of the moment. Strictly speaking, we hear sounds: audible vibrations of any kind. We listen when we attend to them deliberately. Listening demands  far more attention, concentration, and focus. It requires us to quiet our own inner noise and distractions. To listen is to prick up one’s ears, lend an ear, give something of ourselves, and be fully present to another person. Listening requires humility: the ego must step aside and make room within us for the person speaking.

Reducing listening to mere hearing is another symptom of our shallow, deafeningly noisy age. Close attention to language– which is also close attention to thought– makes that unmistakable. In Spanish, people walking down the street or sitting in a café routinely ask into their phones, “¿Me escuchas?” –“Are you listening to me?”– when what they mean is “¿Me oyes?” –“Can you hear me?” They are asking whether their voice is coming through, not whether the other person is paying attention. When hearing and listening collapse into the same undifferentiated act, genuine listening is reduced to passive reception. It loses its particular value; the distinction no longer seems to matter. Why make the effort to listen to someone if simply registering the sound of their voice is enough—and more than enough?

Enough for what, exactly? Enough to get the gist, to form a “rough idea,” as people say. Enough to gather passing impressions that serve as a “springboard” — to borrow an image from Heidegger’s Being and Time– from which the self leaps into the world and claims it as its own. Yet the more we settle for hearing instead of listening deeply, the narrower our understanding becomes. Its horizon closes in and shrinks, cutting us off both from others and from ourselves.

When students in a classroom or hall merely hear a professor’s voice, registering its sound and tone whether they are paying attention or zoning out; when radio and television become background noise, offering little more than the sounds of words and the tribal signals of pundits; when families and couples merely hear one another’s voices, talking over one another while supposedly “listening,” with screens and devices blaring all around them—then the spoken word, the highest expression of humanity, is left in tatters, stripped of its deepest purpose.

Few everyday signs more clearly reveal the deterioration of our shared life more clearly than what has happened to our gathering places: bars, restaurants, and public squares, where we supposedly go to spend some time with others– or to encounter another side of ourselves.  At their heart, these are places for speaking and listening. Yet we have meekly accepted the relentless racket, more or less musical,  that makes the conversation and mutual understanding nearly impossible in some many of them.  Our resignation speaks volumes about our indifference to the degradation of public space and the spoken word. Set aside venues intended for dancing or concerts. Any place where you have to shout over the noise is a sensory madhouse, not a setting for human conversation. The cafés and taverns of earlier times—and the few old-school ones that survive —were sanctuaries of the spoken word. People listened, debated, reflected, exchanged ideas, shared news, founded newspapers, drafted manifestos, read, and wrote. They honored that most human of realms: language, the medium that makes us who we are, lets us understand one another, and makes us less alone. These were places to be genuinely present with others. There is no better way to be together than to speak and be heard.

How often do we find such places today? More broadly, how often do we truly listen? How often are we allowed—and how often do we allow ourselves—to lend an ear and give another person our undivided attention? When someone speaks, how deeply do we listen? How much of ourselves do we bring to the effort to understand?

Today there is noise everywhere: words as noise, the drone of words, words reduced to white noise. We absorb it passively, like any other sensory stimulus. It leaves a vaguely pleasant or unpleasant impression as we endure it, wait for it to stop, or even wallow in it. But what happens when words themselves become little more than noise? What becomes of the realities and events that are not words but depend on words to become meaningful to us? Do they, too, dissolve into noise and indifference?

When we truly listen—even to an actual noise, a faint and unexpected sound—we try to identify its source. We ask what it is, what it means, whether it conveys a message, and why it matters. This is the stance of an attentive human being: someone alert to meaning, sensitive to significance, and genuinely present. A person can be in a room, alone or with others, and be more or less present—or entirely absent. Attention—active, engaged listening, whether to another person or to our own surroundings—is the prerequisite for genuine presence.

The careless way so many Spanish speakers now use escuchar, “to listen”, as a synonym to oír, “to hear”, reveals a dangerous erosion of listening itself. Language, after all, reflects and exposes our inner lives. This confusion  suggests that the effort to understand and pay attention makes no difference as though passively registering sensory impressions were all that mattered. When we treat listening and hearing as interchangeable, stripping listening of the effort and discipline it demands, we imply that attending to, understanding, and weighing another person’s words hardly matters. It is enough simply to receive—or in the current jargon “process” —incoming signals, like hotel clerks handing out room keys or old-fashioned switchboard operators plugging in cords to connect a call.

For those who hear without listening—or see no difference between the two— the “hollow tenors” and “the chorus of crickets,” that Antonio Machado scorned in one of his greatest poems, are more than enough. Hollowness and conformity need only be heard, not listened to. There is nothing to discover in them, except perhaps the question of why the hollow and the conformist enjoy such prestige and success. But anyone content merely to hear will never distinguish “the voices from the echoes,” much less “listen to the one true voice amid the din.” If we still care about telling a genuine human voice from a mechanical, media-driven echo—obedient, trained, and servile—there is only one way to begin: by truly listening. That means, turning our attention first to real voices rather than the surrounding clamor And, among those voices, against all that noise, it means truly listening to one.

Whether the herd mentality of our age—and those who profit from raising sheep—have any interest in our continuing to listen, discern, and judge for ourselves is another question entirely. Almost certainly very little, if any.

Share

Comments 0

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

Related News