Questioning is a Gerund

Share
Share
40
17.11.2026
Knowing how to ask questions may well be the key to wisdom. Drawing on Rilke, Genesis, Socrates, Machado, and Heidegger, this essay explores the depths of genuine questions—the uncomfortable ones, the ones without easy answers, the ones that open our minds rather than close them.

Surely the noblest, most fruitful, and most vital moment in any genuine conversation is the moment we formulate a question—when we begin by asking. More often than not, it is also the moment that demands the most clarity and courage. Knowing how to ask questions—how to turn to someone who knows more than we do and can help see beyond our ignorance, or how to question ourselves honestly enough to confront our own most urgent, unsettling concerns—is more than a good starting point or a reliable method of inquiry. It may well be the very key to wisdom, and even its essence. 

Few tools in the pursuit of knowledge are as powerful or promising as a well-framed, uncomfortable question. How many great discoveries, scientific or philosophical, have sprung from a question that was deeply unsettling or formulated sharply precise? Every genuine question is uncomfortable: it arises from a sense of unease in the person asking, and stirs up unease in the person being asked. The depth of that discomfort often reveals how honestly and accurately the question has been framed -and how seriously it has been received. Curiously, in Spanish we speak of plantear una pregunta: “posing” or “framing” a question with a suggestion of planting it. But we don’t ordinarily speak of “posing” an answer. Questions must be formulated, framed, and brought into being. Answers, by contrast, are simply “given,” as though they were already lying around waiting to be assembled from whatever we already have at hand. We “give an answer,” but we “pose a question.” A genuine question opens things up. It initiates, challenges, unsettles, and creates. Formulating one takes imagination, effort, and courage. All authentic creativity begins in a moment of disorientation—In the disturbance that first compels us to ask. 

Great works of poetry—the enduring ones born of that restless unease—so often begin with a great question, whether stated outright or left implicit. “Who, if I cried out, would hear me among the angelic orders?” Rilke asks in the opening line of the Duino Elegies, before wondering a few lines later: “Ah, whom can we turn to, then?” And his famous Ninth Elegy begins with another unforgettable question:

Why, when this short span of being could be spent like the laurel, a little darker than all the other greens, with tiny waves on the border of every leaf (like the smile of a breeze)—: why then have to be human—and, escaping from fate, keep longing for fate?

In Casiodoro de Reina’s landmark 1569 Spanish translation of the Bible, the first question appears in the words the Lord God addresses to the man: “Where are you?” Soon afterward come two more: “Who told you that you were naked? Have you eaten from the tree of which I commanded you not to eat?” (Genesis 3:9–11). The first question concerns man’s place—where he stands, physically and morally. The second asks who revealed his nakedness to him—or perhaps, who convinced him that he was naked. The third asks whether he has crossed a boundary: whether he has disobeyed. None of these questions seeks information. The One asking them—the God of the biblical narrative—already knows the answers. Instead, the questions bring the truth into the open for the listener to acknowledge it . And each question goes straight to the heart of the matter: Where do we stand? Where does our sense of exposure come from? Why did we cross the line drawn before us?

When the man promptly blames the woman beside him, the Lord God turns to her: “What is this you have done?” She, in turn, blames the serpent. There is always someone else to blame. Yet the question of what we have done—of our actions and their consequences—is so foundational that it is echoed almost immediately in the story of Cain, alongside another question about place: “Where is Abel your brother?”  Then comes, “What have you done?” Earlier in that same chapter, God asks Cain another piercing question: “Why are you angry, and why has your countenance fallen?” The Book of Genesis thus offers a genesis of the essential questions, as though teaching us how to inquire from the very beginning: Where do we stand? Where is our brother? What lies behind human cruelty and rage? And what is the true weight and consequence of our actions?

In Cipriano de Valera’s 1602 revision of Reina’s Bible, a question appears earlier still. It is a loaded question designed to plant doubt while passing itself off as a simple request for clarification: “Did God really say, ‘You shall not eat from any tree in the garden’?” (Genesis 3:1). In that rendering, strikingly, the first question belongs not to God but to the serpent.it is the serpent. 

But let us return to God’s questions—asked by One who already knows the answers—we might wonder: Why ask at all? Does every profound question, like those in Genesis, contain an implicit accusation? Genuine questions challenge us. They demand an accounting, expose faulty assumptions or reckless actions, uncover lies, and clear away misunderstandings. They prod us awake, test what we believe, and call our premises and information into question. They take nothing for granted. In this sense, asking real questions is the fullest expression of what we call “critical thinking”—a phrase so worn down by repetition that, examined critically, it turns out to be both redundant, since all genuine thinking is critical by nature, and a slogan often used to discourage the very thing it claims to promote. Say “critical thinking” three times then go back to sleep: that seems to be the motto of our supposedly critical age.

Socrates was the undisputed master of the question. He moved from the ironic questions directed at those who claimed to be wise, exposing the weakness of their knowledge and the magnitude of their arrogance-  to questions that helped others bring their own understanding into the world. This second method known as maieutics treats questioning as a kind of intellectual birth to knowledge. Through irony, Socartes first exposed the contradictions and shaky assumptions supporting people’s certainties. Once those blinding prejudices and calcified opinions had been cleared away, further questions could help genuine understanding emerge. At its best, questioning does both: first it strips away the mind’s accumulated debris, then, patiently helps new understanding to come to light.

Any conversation worthy of the name ought to begin with a genuinely good question— provided we can still manage to formulate one. That is a far cry from what so often passes for dialogue today, when people mistake conversation for talking at someone, wearing them down, or beating them into submission with words. 

“To hold a dialogue,” Antonio Machado wrote, “ask first; / then… listen.” Notice that Machado doesn’t even mention speaking. It is implied, of course, but only at a possible third step, after asking and listening. Those two come first not merely in sequence, but in importance and depth. Today, we ask few questions and listen even less. What we do endlessly is talking. We chatter because we have mouths. Spanish has an expression for it, hablar hasta por los codos – literally, to talk even through your elbows. In English we can simply say that we don’t stop running our mouths. 

Genuine questioning is something else. It means asking about what we don’t know but need or long to understand. It also means questioning what we think we already know. The history of the Spanish verb preguntar, “to ask” or “to question offers a revealing image.  Its Latin origin connects inquiry with  percontari, to question or investigate, traditionally associated with taking soundings: lowering a long pole into the river or sea to measure its depth. The Latin word for that pole was contus.  To ask, in this image, is to sound the depths—to discover how deep the water runs and whether we can safely navigate those waters. The word’s history also brings in another Latin verb, cunctari: to hesitate, delay, or be uncertain. Through the interplay of these forms came the ancestors of the Spanish preguntar. What a suggestive convergence. On one side, hesitation and doubt, on the other,the effort to discover what lies beneath us and whether the passage ahead is safe. The word itself brings seeking and doubting together , linking the pause of uncertainty with the works of sounding the depths. Anyone who never doubts will make a poor navigator. Without the humility to hesitate, we can fathom very little- least of all the truth beneath the waters of our lives. 

Yet the finest questions—the greatest, perhaps even the most beautiful—are like the finest conversations: they allow no tidy, definite answer. Instead, they compel us to ask again and again, from new perspectives and at different turning points in our lives and in history. The best questions are always the most fundamental. In Being and Time, Martin Heidegger writes that “we must work out the question of the meaning of Being.” If this is indeed a fundamental question- ot the fundamental question- then he adds “then such questioning requires that it become transparent to itself.”

To become transparent: to see through the question itself. To find illumination not so much in a ready-made answer as in the very act of asking. A great question is like a lens, or a clear pane of glass, through which reality comes into focus. “Every questioning is a seeking,” Heidegger continues. “Every seeking takes its prior direction from what is sought. Questioning is a knowing search for a being in its ‘that-it-is’ and ‘what-it-is.’ This knowing search can become an ‘investigation,’ as the revealing determination of what the question is about. Questioning, as a ‘questioning about something,’ has what it asks about.” What distinguishes genuine questioning from idle curiosity—just as meaningful speech differs from empty chatter—is that it “sees through itself.” It examines not only its subject but its own way of asking. Through the question, we come to see: to contemplate in the sense suggested by the ancient Greek theōrein, behold or observe. By seeking and questioning, we allow the truth of what we are investigating to come into view.

But let us step back from the philosophers and their technical language. Let us listen instead to the wisdom that generations have deposited in everyday speech. I can still hear my grandfather repeating the old Spanish proverb: Quien pregunta no yerra—“You can’t go wrong by asking” The saying recorded as far back as Spain’s Golden Age by Sebastián de Covarrubias, suggests that while we can easily go wrong in answering, it is difficult to go wrong by asking an honest question. We might even wonder whether, just as an honest question protects us from error, a genuine question makes lying impossible.  Answers and pronouncements, by contrast, give us ample opportunity to lie – far more often than we care to admit. Errors, lies, and the parade of ideologies are, as Peter Sloterdijk has observed, the three great plagues of our time. Questioning, seeking the truth, and thinking may be their antidotes. Of course Spanish also has the disparaging word preguntón: someone who asks too many questions, a pest, or busybody who can’t stop prying. Tellingly, the word enters the historical record in the early decades of the Enlightenment.

And then there are the ultimate questions—the ones that matter most, unsettle us most deeply, and ought to keep us searching—Paradoxically, these are also the questions most easily slip through our fingers. However frustrating it may be, what matters most seems to escape us just when we think we have finally pinned it down. Mystery opens around us, wider than before. Mystery trembles, the poets tell us. And within that trembling, where our deepest questions begin, we are invited to live in wonder. That is why Schopenhauer called human beings “metaphysical animals”. That is not at all the same thing as calling us  “animalistic metaphysicians,” – though history has certainly had its share of those, too, with all the disastrous consequences that followed.

Share

Comments 0

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

Related News