Human Beings and the Possibility of the Impossible
Human life—the life of a being who says “I”—is profoundly shaped by the impossible. In everyday language, “impossible” describes something that defies logic or falls outside the realm of what can actually happen. Yet the impossible cannot simply be erased from human existence. We cannot dismiss its presence out of hand: not as an illusion or figment of the imagination, but as something real, active, and tangible. From a strictly empirical or practical standpoint, we might object that the impossible is nothing more than an abstraction, a pointless mental exercise. If something is impossible, it simply cannot happen. Period.
But that is far from the whole story. Consider how the impossible lives within the deepest desires and our most searching ideas. Without it, we would no longer imagine or dream, hope or pray. Don’t we exclaim, “That’s impossible!” when an unexpected joy, an encounter, or an event captivates us and takes us by surprise? What has happened is so astonishing, yet it feels so deeply right that we call it “impossible”—so true and so concrete that, paradoxically, it seems impossible! Conversely, don’t we cry out, “This can’t be happening! It’s impossible!” when confronted with searing pain or devastating loss? We give voice to our disbelief when reality leaves us bewildered or shatters our expectations. In both cases, the “possible” alone—the predictable, the controllable, the effect neatly deduced from its cause—cannot fully account for human experience. In the deepest sense, I exist because the impossible has been kindled within me. To put it more boldly: what secretly stirs the heart and mind of the self is precisely the possibility of the impossible. What we call impossible, yet continue to desire, imagine, and hope for, can become possible. This keeps the self from closing in on itself, and opens it instead to an Other capable of reaching, touching, and moving it.
Suppose we paused amid the demands of everyday life with all its necessary routines, to consider what truly drives us. Suppose we look beyond the bookkeeping- The mental balance sheets on which we tally debits and credits, expenses and income. We would discover something striking. We are moved not only by external forces and circumstances but also, perhaps above all, by the quiet expectation that the impossible might actually happen: something unpredictable, something freely given. The trouble is that we usually dismiss this expectation as irrational- a pipe dream and therefore unreal. We tell ourselves not to get carried away if we want to remain sensible “realists”. Yet however unrealistic the object of our hope may seem, hope itself has an undeniable power. It can be silenced, brushed aside, or stifled, but never eradicated. What if, on the contrary, the impossible were, in fact, essential to the life of the self? Not a literary utopia or romantic fantasy, but something genuinely real—perhaps even the fullest expression of realism?
Here lies the contradiction woven into the very fabric of our humanity. It is not merely logical or psychological, but ontological: it concerns our very being. The self exists, by its nature, through something that reaches beyond it. In terms of lived experience, impossibility does not mean that a human being can never become more than what they already are. On the contrary, it means that each person is called beyond themselves, toward something greater that lies beyond his own grasp.
The question is not one of “doing the impossible,” but of being the impossible. The legal tradition of ancient Rome already recognized limits on any obligation to do the impossible, as expressed in the familiar maxim associated with Justinian’s Digest: Ad impossibilia nemo tenetur—no one is bound to do what is objectively impossible. Where performance is impossible, the obligation does not hold. In the ancient world, however, the impossible meant more than what human beings could not accomplish- with the possible exceptions of heroes, who resembled the gods despite their mortality. It was also the immovable wall against which every human possibility shattered: the unyielding necessity of a cosmic order that is what it is and cannot be otherwise. This order was at once logical and philosophical -think of Parmenides- and natural and religious. The only conceivable opening in that order appears in the moving “Lament of Danaë,” preserved in a fragment by Simonides of Ceos. Facing death at sea with her infant son, Danaë begs for the impossible: “Sleep, my child, I pray you; let the sea sleep, let our boundless sorrow sleep—and may some change of heart come from you, Father Zeus!” (fr. 543 P).
Against the backdrop of the possible, constrained by the inexorable necessity governing mortal life, the impossible seems to belong entirely to the divine. Only a God – or magic or rituals intended to evoke divine intervention- could bring it about. It is precisely here that the Judeo-Christian revolution takes place. Throughout the Gospels, the impossible runs like a golden thread of grace. It appears in the angel’s announcement of two miraculous pregnancies: that of the young Mary, who asks, “How will this be, since I am a virgin?” and that of her elderly cousin Elizabeth, long considered unable to conceive children. The explanation is that “nothing will be impossible with God” (Luke 1:34–37). It appears again in the astonishing possibility that a rich man might be saved— something harder than a camel passing through the eye of a needle—because “what is impossible with man is possible with God” (Luke 18:27; Matthew 19:26).
What is most striking about this new understanding, however, is that the impossible does not enter human life as a deus ex machina, an arbitrary intervention from above that resolves a hopeless plot. Something far deeper is at stake. As a gift from God, the impossible becomes the very possibility through which human beings can become truly themselves. The impossible becomes a human possibility. Here, the freely given is no longer equated with the irrational or the absurd. Instead, it is understood as the gift of a relationship that sets us free. Paul of Tarsus, once a fierce defender of the boundary the law draws between the possible and the impossible, offers powerful testimony to this transformation. On the road to Damascus, he is overtaken -and literally blinded- by the impossible. He becomes the living embodiment of an impossibility that no longer negates life but brings something new into being. As Paul writes in his Letter to the Galatians (2:15 ff.), we are justified not by “works of the law”—what we can accomplish through our own strength—but through “faith in Jesus Christ.” “I have been crucified with Christ,” he declares. It is as though he has reached the absolute limit of human striving, the point at which every human possibility collapses, only to discover that a new “I” has become possible: “It is no longer I who live, but Christ who lives in me.”
This reveals a new meaning in the contradiction that arises when the impossible breaks into the possible. It is as though the Christian event had freed the impossible from the confines of natural necessity and strict logical deduction- both of which remain fully valid within their own domains- and unleashed it into history as something genuinely new and alive. The impossible no longer elicits the skeptical laughter of an aging Sarah. Instead, it reawakens the promise made to Abraham and his descendants.
Many centuries later, this struggle with the impossible finds a powerful echo in Giacomo Leopardi, a thinker essential to understanding the modern human condition. Throughout his poetry and prose, we encounter his unsparing recognition of an unresolvable contradiction at the heart of human nature. In his Zibaldone, for example, Leopardi asks how anyone can “explain the terrifying mystery of things and of universal existence”: although we are naturally drawn to seek happiness, the very structure of our existence prevents us from attaining it. To explain this, he writes, we would have to concede that a foundational principle of reason—that “a thing cannot both be and not be at the same time”—is “utterly false.” More starkly still, we would have to acknowledge that “the very being of living creatures stands in a natural, essential, and necessary contradiction with itself.” On one hand, Leopardi asks: “Who can fathom these monstrosities?”How can it be that “for living beings, non-existence is infinitely better than existence”? To exist, on his account, necessarily means unhappiness: we can’t experience pleasure as we truly desire it- that is, without limits (Zibaldone, 4099–4100). On the other hand, he acknowledges that he stands before a “great mystery that can never be explained, except by denying […] every absolute truth or falsehood” (4129).
Yet it is precisely at this impasse that the positive meaning of the impossible comes to life again. Alongside the bleak recognition of universal unhappiness stands our equally undeniable, deeply felt desire for happiness. If the former is real, the latter is no less so. The contradiction itself can therefore point toward the possibility of the impossible—toward the infinite we long for. For that longing is already present within us, setting our lives in motion.

