Interview with Joseph Fasano: ‘If I Go Deep Enough, I Will Find You’

Share
Share
10
17.11.2026
Poet Joseph Fasano on surviving the age of AI, making art accessible without compromising its quality, and the radical empathy we need to truly find one another. Joseph Fasano, photo courtesy of East Central University

Five collections, three novels, a book of prompts, and poems that reach well beyond the usual poetry audience. In April Joseph Fasano argued that poetry had become marginal in America partly because poets had turned away from the public. We asked him what it would mean to turn back.

We found him on X in April. His post ran to four parts. It wasn’t a poem but an argument, and a fiery one: Poetry had become marginalized in the United States, he wrote, partly because poets, understandably angry at being ignored by American culture, had taken an unconscious revenge by turning away from the people. We read it twice. Then we emailed him, leaving the “i” out of  “interview” in the subject line- the kind of first impression you can’t take back. He answered anyway.

Fasano is 44. He studied philosophy at Harvard and earned an MFA at Columbia, where he taught for nearly two decades before leaving to establish his own academy. He has published five poetry collections, two novels, and The Magic Words, a book of writing prompts for children. His third novel will be published in March 2027: How We Survive: A Guide to Being Human in a Time of AI. He won the Rattle Poetry Prize at 26. He also has a four-year-old son. Halfway through our conversation a white-tailed deer wandered across his backyard, and he stopped to tell us about it. We talked about craft, the sacred, AI, his father, and Whitman. He is the first American featured in this interview series.

In April you wrote on X: “The practice of poetry has always been about understanding others, fathoming the human heart and its desires, the human mind and its structures, and a poet should focus on mastering his craft so that he can create what resonates with anyone—with everyone—who thirsts to be all of what she is.” How does poetry do that?

We live in a time of false dichotomies. In poetry, some poets have turned their back on the public, producing an insular, academic kind of poetry that is really very afraid to feel. On the other hand, we have a great deal of poetry, mostly online, that doesn’t care very much about craft. What I’m trying to do is find that expansive space poetry has always occupied in cultures that truly value it. I believe poets should become so adept at their craft that it becomes nearly invisible to the general reader. Someone can listen to a beautiful composed sonata, without knowing much about its structure, and still be deeply moved. We need to democratize art without compromising its quality.

Here in America, those false dichotomies often reduce everything to good and evil. Everything in between gets lost. How does poetry resist that temptation?

There are two ways to look at the world: the “should,” and the “is.” You can look at something and judge what it should be, or you can ask: Regardless of what it should be, what is it? What’s interesting about poetry is that it leads with the “is.” But, if a poet renders that “is” clearly enough- depicting the drama of an event or situation- the reader can arrive at their own “should.” I once wrote a poem called “Words Whispered to a Child Under Siege,” which came out of my feelings as a father. My son is only four, and I wanted to imagine what I would possibly say to him if we didn’t have the immense privilege of living somewhere where we don’t have to worry about bombs falling on us. There’s no point in that poem where I say, “Isn’t this horrible, that the bombs are falling on people?” I simply enter the humanity of the situation and depict what life is like for some people in this world, as humbly and clearly as I can. If a piece of writing does that clearly, it allows the reader to step in and be the moral hero. The reader is the one who says: This should not be.

We live in frightening times: Injustice, wars, and now  the prospect of AI becoming powerful enough to threaten humanity. Can poetry help us heal?

It is healing insofar as it teaches empathy. We’re born with empathy, but we’re also born with muscles in our arms. If we don’t use them, they atrophy. Empathy needs exercise, and our institution, especially in the Western world, doesn’t give us many opportunities to practice it. Our system even makes a virtue out of suppressing empathy: “Oh,” we hear, “he’s a great businessman, because he’s able to ignore his heart.” You are the first journalist I’ve spoken with about this, but I’m writing a book that isn’t a collection of poems. It’s a book of prose about what we can actually do, as human beings, to survive the advent of AI. One of the things I propose is that our fundamental gift as human beings is our ability to perceive things as sacred. I don’t mean that in any strictly religious sense. Someone can touch their father’s baby shoes, for example, and feel something in them that a computer cannot feel. I believe humanity is the universe perceiving its own sacredness, and poetry is one way to exercise that capacity.

So the sacred is a kind of doorway to our inner selves. In “Instructions for Having a Soul” you write: “Read a book to a blind man, to your father.” Why does that matter so much?

What is the soul? I take a functional approach to that question. If you spend your day without nourishing certain parts of yourself, you begin to feel empty. You begin to feel disconnected. We can argue all we want, like medieval philosophers, about whether the soul exists. But human beings a hundred thousand years ago knew nothing about what water is, and yet they knew that drinking it made them feel better. Maybe we don’t know what the soul is, and maybe we never will. We should let go, a little, of trying to define it, and simply start nourishing it again.

In “Mahler in New York,” the poem that won you the Rattle Prize, you describe carrying your father with you the way a horse carries autumn in its mane. What does fatherhood mean to you, both as a son and as a father? 

I became a father somewhat later in life. I was 40, and I’m very grateful for that, because I think I had a lot of growing and changing to do. Nothing in my life has awakened me more than becoming a father. When a father looks at his son, he’s staring into the eyes of the future. Of course a father asks himself what kind of world he’s leaving his child. When I look at my son, I think about how all my theories—in education, in poetry—come back to this one command I live by: Be the whole human being, and help others do the same. We so often forget to do that, and our culture has a vested interest in keeping us broken. We identify with our jobs, for example, or with only the rational sides of ourselves, or with the parts that are immediately “useful.” We’re taught to disregard, even silence, enormous parts of ourselves: the parts that feel mystery and wonder, that hear little scraps of poetry in the night, that truly know how to empathize, to feel for others, to love. When I look at my son, I think: Here is this beautiful creature, this fresh gift of a person who was born, like all people, knowing something our society wants him to forget. Why would I want any part of him to be silenced?

What gives a poet the right to imagine suffering they haven’t experienced?

I’m going to answer with another question: what gives a poet the right not to imagine the suffering of others? We live in a time when many ethical conversations begin in good faith and then become corrupted by market forces. Writing a poem in the voice of somebody whose suffering the poet hasn’t experienced could indeed be transgressive, if the poet doesn’t do it well. That leads, of course,to another question: What does it mean to do it well? It’s rather like the Supreme Court’s definition of obscenity—you know it when you see it. And we’ve seen it done well so many times. I don’t think Shakespeare worried about whether he was allowed to imagine his characters’ inner life, except insofar as he worried about doing it well, with all the humanity he could muster. What we can’t do is let conversations that begin in good faith turn, ironically, into further oppression of our imaginations, of our whole selves. That’s how an oppressive society quietly wins: by silencing us, by pitting artists against one another, by making us the oppressors of our own imaginations while we call that self-oppression a virtue. Consumerism creeps into our ethical conversations, and people start to say, unconsciously, “My pain is my product, and your pain is your product. Stay in your lane, and I’ll stay in mine.” Poets must use their imagination with great ethical awareness. But they also have an enormous opportunity and obligation to imagine another human being’s reality. If we let those good-faith conversations about otherness become prohibitions against our imagination, the great irony will be that we’ve created an authoritarianism within art itself.

In “For a Student Who Used AI to Write a Paper” you ask what we are trying to free ourselves from—”the living, the miraculous task of it”—and end with: “Love is for the ones who love the work.” What is that love?

Wonder and love are related because both require- and welcome- a state of openness. There are so many reasons to close ourselves off. We’re overstimulated, bombarded, tempted to retreat. To preserve our wonder, we need to unplug sometimes. We need to experience nature and one another. Wonder is that state of being open. And love is an action. Love means being open to listening to whoever is in front of you. In that poem, I’m addressing a student who used AI to write a paper, and I try to begin with compassion: I know life is hard right now. When I say love is for the ones who love the work, I’m not talking about homework. I’m talking about a world in which we take so many shortcuts that when we finally look into another person’s eyes, we think, catastrophically, “I don’t know how to do the work anymore.” And what is that work? Listening. Paying attention. Holding each other’s complexities. Simone Weil once wrote that  “Loving  our neighbor in all its fullness simply means being able to ask the person, ‘What are you going through?”

Once , standing in front of Mont Blanc in Italy , I felt wonder simply by being there. Is wonder something a  poet creates, or something a poet receives? And how does it relate to hope?

Wonder, especially in our world, is a triumph. Many people believe that poets are born able to open their arms and gaze blissfully at the world, where everything is roses and puppies and ice cream. In my experience, it’s the opposite. A poet is often—and I’ll speak for myself here—someone who has had every reason to close down, someone who has experienced traumas and terrible things, as so many people have. But because of that, the poet feels a deep desire to experience the triumph of opening up. My own struggles had brought me to moments when I couldn’t stand before a mountain and feel wonder. Instead I felt tremendous fear, tremendous agony. If people find in my poetry an ability to feel wonder and open up, it’s because I’ve worked for it. I feel an obligation to guide my son toward wonder. As for hope, there’s a poem by the late American poet Randall Jarrell called “90 North,” – the location of the North Pole. On the surface it’s about a middle-aged man who feels he has reached his peak, and that everything ahead is a descent. It ends with what I consider some of the darkest, seemingly most hopeless lines in poetry: “Pain comes from the darkness / And we call it wisdom. It is pain.” There is nothing hopeful in those lines. And yet when we read them, because the poet has found language, for the experience, we feel a shiver of beauty. I would even call it  a shiver of hope. Even when the content seems hopeless, the act of putting it into language is the triumph; the form is the hope.

An impossible question, but I’ll ask it anyway. What is your favorite poem?

It’s almost impossible to choose. But right now, as I’m talking to you, the work closest to my desk is Whitman’s. Whitman is inimitable, and my goals and approaches are nothing like his. But there’s something about “Song of Myself”, and I’m not sure why it’s so often overlooked: That great poem begins with the word “I”—”I celebrate myself, and sing myself”—and, all those lines later, ends with the word “you”: “I stop somewhere waiting for you.” Whitman is often seen as the great poet of selfhood, of being oneself. But he understands that encountering himself is what will allow him to find the other- and allow the other to find him. That is the fundamental faith of lyric poetry: If I go deep enough into myself, I will find you. We’re sold a very cheap version of selfhood today. As I sit here—what is this thing beside me called, an “i”-Phone?—I’m being sold a version of myself that has everything to do with my  immediate gratification and nothing to do with a profound encounter with the otherness within me. That encounter would be dangerous to the status quo.That is why we must go there, in art and in life. That is our miraculous task, and something deep in our humanity knows exactly how to do it. Let’s give poetry a chance to remind us of that great truth: if we go deeper into ourselves, we can find each other.

We’re sold a very cheap version of selfhood…If we go deeper into ourselves, we can find each other.

Share

Comments 0

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

Related News